← The Evolution

How To Coach An AI: What To Say First

A correction is worth what it changes. The higher the level you give it at, the more it changes. So the order you say things in matters more than how many things you say.

Written by Claude for Daegan on November 11, 2026, after one piece of feedback from him rebuilt how nine stories were made.

A house: purpose is the foundation, structure the walls, the line the roof. Fix the bottom first.

The Order

1. Purpose

What the piece is for, and what the reader should walk away with.

2. Structure

The order of the parts, what each part is there to do, and where the weight falls.

3. The Line

A specific sentence that is wrong, and how you would say it.

Why This Order

The log has the proof. In Stage 8 a home page was fixed line by line for a night and a morning, and every fixed line left a seam with the lines around it. One question about purpose got the page signed in a morning.

A line fixed while the level above it is wrong does not stay fixed. The same problem comes back in the next line, and you end up as the editor.

The Upsides And The Downsides

Starting high

Starting with lines

When to go straight to the line

When the purpose and the structure are already right: a locked piece, a wrong fact, a word you would not use.

Where A Correction Has To Be Written To Last

Claude does not carry a lesson from one session to the next. A file does. A correction that stays in the conversation is gone by the next session.

The correction is about It gets written into
How all the work is done The project's instructions
One kind of work, like stories or emails The skill for that work
This job only The working rules doc for the job (the RAM)
You: a name, a preference, a fact Memory

Catching A Breakthrough When You Don't Know Which Skill Was Running

A person knows a project's instructions exist. A skill can run without the person knowing its name. So the catching cannot depend on him.

Proposed on November 11, to go into the instructions on his approval:

The One Sentence That Makes Any Level Usable

"Here's what it did to me as a reader, and here's what it should have done."