← Fishers Funnel

Who Wins The Registration Page?

Four copywriters each rewrote our Fishers registration page (the live October 20 version), and the council's six-change revision ran too. The same 100 simulated local owners read every version cold on a phone, each version blind to the others.

Brunson18
Jimmy D. Brown17
Ours16
Belcher16
Council15
Plank14

No clear winner. Our own page against an almost identical revision moved 5 readers and landed 16 to 15, so a gap of one or two is noise. Brunson's +2 and Jimmy D. Brown's +1 are inside it.

What every version shared: people who said no mostly said Tuesday night (55 to 64 readers), the drive (41 to 47), or "free means a pitch" (35 to 42). No rewrite moved those numbers.

The one lever that showed up: the form. It cost registrations in four of the five versions, and the more the copy spelled out the address and website fields, the more it cost: Plank lost 4 to it, Belcher 2, Jimmy D. Brown 2, Brunson 1. Readers wanted in and said "I'll do it later."

Use these for split testing. Every version here is a ready option for the live split test once traffic runs. Its simulated number is the prediction the real result gets compared to: if the live page beats or trails its simulation, that gap tells us how well the simulation reads this audience. Brunson's P.S. line "it may be the last free one" isn't in our facts and comes out before it runs.

How the simulation ran

October 25, 2026. 100 simulated local business owners within driving distance of Fishers, varied by business, years open, team size, tech comfort, attitude, distance, Tuesday availability, age and reading habits. 57 came through the opt-in, 43 landed cold.

Each version was read by four separate readers, 25 owners each, on a phone, without seeing any other version. Each owner reported: registered or not, how likely to show up, how far they read, the line that moved them, the line where they stopped, and why, in their own words.

Every version is paired owner by owner against ours, so a flip is one person changing their mind. The noise check is ours against the council's near-identical revision: 5 flips, 16 to 15. A version needs to beat ours by more than two or three before we call it a win.